Big Poppa's Pizza menu
Big Poppa’s Pizza Menu
NY Hand-Tossed • Chicago-Style Deep Dish • Specialty Pies • Appetizers • DessertsLarge Group Orders & Catering
For any Large Group Orders or Catering, please contact us at (605) 271-0925 or fill out our Catering Contact Form. Our team would love to help plan your next event!
Hand-Tossed Pizzas
All Hand-Tossed pizzas include a marinara base and 1 topping in the price. To swap out house marinara base with a Specialty sauce +$2. Specialty Sauce options: Alfredo • BBQ • Buffalo • Garlic Butter • Hot Honey.
Build Your Own (Hand-Tossed)
Medium $11.99 • Large $14.99 • XL $17.99 • GF $15.99
Veggies +$2 each • Meats +$3 each.
Specialty Pizzas (Hand-Tossed)
Butcher’s Block
Pepperoni, Canadian Bacon, Sausage, Beef, Bacon.
Medium $23.99 • Large $26.99 • XL $29.99 • GF $27.99
Chicken Alfredo
Alfredo, Chicken, Bacon, Onions.
Medium $21.99 • Large $24.99 • XL $27.99 • GF $25.99
Tuscan Chicken
Alfredo, Garlic Chicken, Spinach, Bacon Bits, Mushrooms, Tomatoes.
Medium $25.99 • Large $28.99 • XL $31.99 • GF $29.99
Hot Momma
Marinara, Pecorino Romano, Red Pepper Flake, Mozzarella, Pepperoni, Bacon, Hot Honey.
Medium $19.99 • Large $22.99 • XL $25.99 • GF $23.99
Supreme
Pepperoni, Canadian Bacon, Sausage, Beef, Bacon, Mushrooms, Onions, Bell Peppers, Black Olives.
Medium $29.99 • Large $32.99 • XL $35.99 • GF $33.99
Veggie
Bell Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Black Olives.
Medium $17.99 • Large $20.99 • XL $23.99 • GF $21.99
BBQ Chicken
BBQ Sauce, Chicken, Bacon, Onion.
Medium $18.99 • Large $21.99 • XL $24.99 • GF $22.99
Aloha Delight
Canadian Bacon, Pineapple, Bacon Bits.
Medium $16.99 • Large $19.99 • XL $23.99 • GF $21.99
Chicago-Style Deep Dish
Cook time ~30–50 minutes. Marinara base. Specialty sauces +$2.
Build Your Own (Deep Dish)
Medium $33.99 • Large $37.99
Veggies +$2 each • Meats +$3 each.
Specialty Pizzas (Deep Dish)
Butcher’s Block
Pepperoni, Canadian Bacon, Sausage, Beef, Bacon.
Medium $45.99 • Large $49.99
Chicken Alfredo
Alfredo, Chicken, Bacon, Onions.
Medium $41.99 • Large $45.99
Tuscan Chicken
Alfredo, Garlic Chicken, Spinach, Bacon Bits, Mushrooms, Tomatoes.
Medium $44.99 • Large $48.99
Hot Momma
Marinara, Pecorino Romano, Red Pepper Flake, Mozzarella, Pepperoni, Bacon, Hot Honey.
Medium $41.99 • Large $45.99
Supreme
Pepperoni, Canadian Bacon, Sausage, Beef, Bacon, Mushrooms, Onions, Bell Peppers, Black Olives.
Medium $49.99 • Large $53.99
Veggie
Bell Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Black Olives.
Medium $39.99 • Large $43.99
BBQ Chicken
BBQ Sauce, Chicken, Bacon, Onion.
Medium $40.99 • Large $44.99
Aloha Delight
Canadian Bacon, Pineapple, Bacon Bits.
Medium $39.99 • Large $43.99
Toppings & Specialty Sauces
Veggies – $2 each
Mushrooms • Onions • Bell Peppers • Jalapeños • Pepperoncini • Black Olives • Pineapple • Green Olives • Tomatoes • Spinach • Extra Cheese
Meats – $3 each
Pepperoni • Italian Sausage • Smoked Bacon • Beef • Canadian Bacon • Grilled Chicken
Specialty Sauce Options +$2: Alfredo • BBQ • Buffalo • Garlic Butter • Hot Honey
Appetizers & Calzones
Cheese Bread
$12.99
Large order, served with marinara.
Homemade Garlic Knots
$7.99
Soft, buttery garlic knots with marinara.
Bread Sticks (8)
$9.99
Large order of 8 garlic-buttered sticks with marinara.
Calzones
$12.99
Add Meats +$3 each • Add Veggies +$2 each.
Desserts
Dessert Pizza
XL buttery crust with streusel, cream cheese frosting, and your choice of chocolate or caramel drizzle.
Plain $19.99 • Apple $20.99 • Cherry $20.99 • Snickers $22.99 • Butterfinger $22.99 • Smores $22.99
New York Style Cheesecake Slice
$5.79
Add your favorite toppings: Butterfinger, Snickers, Caramel, or Chocolate.
Pizza By The Slice & Lunch - In Store Ordering Only
Hand-Tossed Slice
$4.75
Flavors vary by day.
Deep Dish Slice
$7.00
Flavors vary by day.
9" Personal Pizza (Lunch Only)
$9.99
Any toppings
Stromboli (Lunch only)
$7.50
Golden baked roll filled with mozzarella and your choice of flavor:
• Pepperoni
• Pepperoni & Sausage
• Supreme • Butcher’s Block
Beverages
Fountain Pop
$2.79
Enjoy your favorite ice-cold fountain drink. Available flavors include:
• Coke
• Diet Coke
• Sprite
• Mr. Pibb
• Root Beer
• Mello Yello
• Lemonade
• Water
20oz Coke Products (Bottled)
$2.79
Assorted Coca-Cola bottled beverages available in:
• Coke
• A&W Root Beer
• Diet Coke • Powerade Purple
• Cherry Coke
• Powerade Red
• Coke Zero
• Powerade Red
• Sprite
• Powerade Blue
• Lemonade • Apple Juice
• Fanta Pineapple
• White Milk
• Fanta Strawberry • Chocolate Milk
• Fanta Orange
Bottled Water
$1.99
Refreshing bottled spring water.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can we do half and half pizzas?
Yes! You can do half and half pizzas on Hand-Tossed and Gluten-Free pizzas. We do not allow half and half on Deep Dish pizzas. Please note that multiple sauces are not permitted on a half and half pizza.
How long does a Hand-Tossed Pizza take?
When there are no tickets in front of your order, Hand-Tossed pizzas take approximately 15–20 minutes to prepare and bake from start to finish. Times may vary depending on order volume.
How long does a Deep Dish Pizza take?
Deep Dish pizzas take approximately 30–50 minutes to prepare and bake from start to finish when there are no tickets ahead. Cook times may vary depending on order volume.
How long does a Gluten-Free Pizza take?
Gluten-Free pizzas typically take 15–20 minutes to prepare and bake from start to finish when there are no tickets ahead. Cook times may vary depending on order volume.
How long does a 9" Personal Pizza take?
Our 9" Personal Pizzas take approximately 10–15 minutes to prepare and bake from start to finish when there are no tickets ahead. Cook times may vary depending on order volume.
How long does a Calzone take?
Calzones take approximately 10–20 minutes
